Here is an image of Longs Peak (the flat-topped peak in the far distance) photographed from Rock Cut in Rocky Mountain National Park. Longs Peak is a very popular subject for photographs, and Rock Cut is a very popular (and very accessible) location along Trail Ridge Road from which to photograph it.
Photographing subjects that are very popular seems to engender much discussion among photographers. One school of thought seems to treat iconic subjects much like trophies to be hunted and bagged. In the same way that a trophy hunter might have a collection of stuffed animal heads on his or her wall, this approach tends to suggest that a photographer’s portfolio is not complete without a collection of iconic subjects that have been stalked and captured. The criticism to this approach is that it lends itself to producing cliched, repetitive photographs lacking in creativity and originality.
Another touted approach is to ignore subjects that are very popular. The thinking seems to be that great photographs can be found anywhere (which is true!), and photographing subjects that are very popular is at best a crutch in producing compelling photographs, and at worst a substitute for true artistic expression. The drawback here is that much compelling subject matter is passed over in order to avoid the risk of producing derivative and repeated imagery.
So what’s the right way to approach photographing a popular location? Myself, I just don’t think about it one way or the other. My personal feeling is that a photographer with a strong personal vision and the discipline to follow it honestly will inevitably produce images that have his or her unique stamp on them.
I’ve spent a fair amount of time photographing Longs Peak. I don’t do so to be part of the crowd (indeed, I’ve passed by and have no interest in photographing a great number of very popular subjects). But I also don’t avoid Longs Peak just because it is popular. I photograph Longs Peak because it speaks to me on a personal level. In this way, it’s no different than any other subject I photograph, and I treat it no differently when I photograph it. To me, that’s the best way to approach photographing a popular location.